| Miscellaneous | Staten Island Cricket Club (1877-1889) |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Second XI (1877-1888) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Cricketers (1878) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Next XXII (1879) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Americans (1883-1886) | |
| Rest of Staten Island (1883) | |
| American Born (1889) |