| Halifax Cup | Staten Island Cricket Club (1922) |
| Miscellaneous | Staten Island Cricket Club Juniors (1884-1888) |
| Staten Island Cricket Club (1885-1926) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Second XI (1886-1895) | |
| St George's Club of New York (1887) | |
| Newark (1887) | |
| Walkers and Ogilbys (1887) | |
| American Born (1889) | |
| St George's Athletic Club (1893) | |
| All New York (1895-1900) | |
| Staten Island and New Jersey Athletic Clubs (1896) | |
| New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1900) | |
| Livingston Field Club (1900-1902) | |
| Livingston (1902) | |
| New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1914) | |
| New York Veterans (1915-1919) | |
| H Manley's XI (1915) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Americans (1916) | |
| EO Challenger's XI (1919) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club 1920 (1920) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Cricketers (1921) | |
| Crescent Athletic Club (1923) |