| Miscellaneous | Staten Island Cricket Club (1877-1882) |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Second XI (1878-1883) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Cricketers (1878) | |
| New York Cricket Club (1889-1901) | |
| New York West (1890) | |
| Fort Hamilton (1891) | |
| All New York (1891-1899) | |
| Manhattan (1891-1893) | |
| All Brooklyn (1891) | |
| New York Cricket Club Second XI (1894) | |
| Nelson Lodge (1901) | |
| Nelson Lodge Second XI (1901) | |
| New York Veterans (1903-1905) |