| Halifax Cup | Staten Island Cricket Club (1922) |
| Westchester-Biltmore (1923-1924) | |
| Miscellaneous | Brooklyn (1900-1913) |
| Brooklyn B (1900-1906) | |
| West Indian (1900) | |
| Brooklyn Second XI (1902-1909) | |
| New York Cricket Association (1903) | |
| Livingston Field Club (1904) | |
| Brooklyn Wanderers (1905) | |
| HA Laurie's XI (1906) | |
| Prospect Park Zingari (1907) | |
| Zingari (1908) | |
| Richmond County (1910-1916) | |
| New York Veterans (1911-1915) | |
| New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1914) | |
| Married of New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1914) | |
| RS Walker's XI (1914) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club (1917-1924) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Veterans (1917) | |
| All New York (1918) | |
| EO Challenger's XI (1919) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club 1919 (1920) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Cricketers (1921) | |
| All Staten Island (1921) |