Teams George Nicholls played for

MiscellaneousSpalding (1853-1855)
 Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge (1855)
 Stamford (1855)
 Margate (1864)
 Peterborough (1865-1866)
 Horncastle (1866-1867)
 Gentlemen of Lincolnshire (1866-1874)
 Lincolnshire (1867-1874)
 Grantham (1868)
 Sleaford (1870)